“I verified it” is a claim, not proof. Keep the brief and source packet open side by side. The assistant’s checklist helps it produce the work; your check determines whether you accept it.
Inspect these five things
| Check | What to look for |
|---|---|
| Coverage | Keeping the current phone and all three new models are considered. |
| Evidence | Important prices, dates, and features point to a passage that actually supports them. |
| Costs | Tax is included; no invented service price, trade-in, discount, or financing makes a phone affordable. |
| Judgment | The recommendation follows this buyer’s needs. An attractive feature cannot cancel a hard limit. |
| Uncertainty | Starting prices remain estimates; battery performance, comfort, service, and delivery gaps are visible. |
Choose one meaningful claim and follow it back to the source. A citation that mentions the topic without supporting the claim does not pass.
Check-in: which passage did you inspect, and what exactly did it support?
Recalculate independently
Use a calculator rather than asking the same assistant whether it got the math right.
Starting price + (starting price × 0.08) = teaching estimate with tax
| New phone | Starting price | Assumed 8% tax | Total | Within $1,500 at this price? |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| iPhone 18 Pro | $1,199.00 | $95.92 | $1,294.92 | Yes |
| iPhone 18 Pro Max | $1,299.00 | $103.92 | $1,402.92 | Yes |
| iPhone Duo | $1,999.00 | $159.92 | $2,158.92 | No |
These are starting-price estimates, not checkout quotes. The packet does not establish a personalized trade-in credit or final configuration price. Keeping the current phone means no new purchase now, not zero future costs or a fix for the charging problem.
Watch tax change the comparison.
A sticker price is not an all-in cost. Add the assumed tax before deciding what fits.
Does the conclusion follow?
- Does it recommend the Duo despite the budget? A folding screen does not make the cost constraint disappear.
- Does it assume the Pro Max is comfortable one-handed without evidence? The name alone does not establish physical fit.
- Does it promise a battery improvement for this person based only on a manufacturer’s claim? That needs a qualification.
- Does it call a future feature available today? The packet says Pencil support for Duo is expected later in 2026, with no precise date.
- Does it recommend keeping the old phone without acknowledging the afternoon charging? Saving money leaves that problem unresolved.
A different recommendation from the reference is not automatically wrong. It must still respect the requirements, show its evidence, and explain the uncertainty.
Accept it or return a correction
If the brief passes, say what you checked and save it. If not, name the defect and the acceptance check. For example, only if the response omitted tax:
Your budget comparison left out the assumed 8% sales tax. Recalculate the
three starting-price totals, update budget eligibility, and revise any
conclusion that changes. Preserve the source packet and all other buyer
requirements. Show the corrected arithmetic, then stop.
Do not manufacture an error just to practice a repair. If your answer passes, explain how you know. If a material fact is still missing, a conditional recommendation can pass when it identifies the gap honestly; an invented fact cannot.
Check the arithmetic, not the confidence.
This deliberately incomplete practice example left out tax. It is not a claim that your assistant made this mistake.
Check-in: would you accept this brief, return one correction, or withhold a purchase decision pending more evidence? Give one reason.
Stop after one focused correction during class. Save unresolved issues with the result rather than spending the rest of the session in an endless retry loop.